Regulation

Fourth Circuit rules 2-1 against Kalshi in its fight with Maryland over sports event contracts

The appeals court upheld the denial of Kalshi's request to block Maryland's sports wagering laws, but the two judges in the majority gave different reasons and the third dissented.

Contents
  1. What the court decided
  2. Two routes to the same result
  3. A growing split among appeals courts
  4. What Kalshi and Maryland said
  5. What comes next
  6. What it could mean for prediction market users

A federal appeals court ruled against Kalshi on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, in the prediction market's challenge to Maryland's sports wagering laws. A three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed a district court's refusal to grant Kalshi a preliminary injunction, voting 2-1. The decision leaves Kalshi without a court order shielding its sports event contracts from Maryland's licensing requirements while the case goes on.

What the court decided

The ruling is a short per curiam opinion affirming the district court, joined by Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker. Each wrote a separate concurring opinion, and Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. The panel heard argument on May 7, 2026.

The case started with a cease-and-desist letter that Maryland's gaming regulators sent Kalshi on April 7, 2025, according to Gregory's opinion. The regulators said Kalshi needed a state sports wagering license, which comes with data security obligations and advertising restrictions. Kalshi sued on April 21, 2025, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) exclusive jurisdiction over its contracts and so preempts, or overrides, Maryland law. District Judge Adam B. Abelson denied a preliminary injunction on August 1, 2025.

Two routes to the same result

Gregory did not decide whether Kalshi's sports contracts are swaps, a category of derivatives the CEA places under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction. Even assuming they are, he wrote, the law does not clearly let them trade free of state gaming laws. Because gambling regulation "has long been a matter of traditional state police power," he would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland's authority "absent a clear expression of its intent to do so."

Thacker took the opposite path. She concluded that Kalshi's sports contracts "are not swaps within the meaning of the CEA," which puts them outside the CFTC's exclusive authority and lets Maryland regulate them alongside federal rules.

Benjamin, in dissent, found that the contracts are swaps and that Maryland's laws are therefore "field preempted." She would have vacated the district court's order and sent the case back to weigh the remaining injunction factors.

A growing split among appeals courts

Gregory's opinion lists the earlier appellate rulings. The Sixth Circuit, in Kalshi's Ohio case, and the Ninth Circuit found no preemption, both concluding the sports contracts are not swaps or likely not swaps. The Third Circuit, in the New Jersey case, held the contracts are swaps under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction and sided with Kalshi. CoinDesk counted the Maryland ruling as the third of four appellate decisions in favor of state oversight. District courts are divided too; on November 10 a New York federal judge ruled against Novig, another prediction market.

Friend-of-the-court briefs backing Maryland included ones from Nevada, Ohio, 36 other states and the District of Columbia, the American Gaming Association and tribal groups, according to the opinion. Paradigm Operations and Underdog Sports Holding filed in support of Kalshi.

What Kalshi and Maryland said

A Kalshi spokeswoman told CoinDesk that "Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong," calling the decision splintered and saying it shows "no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets." InGame carried the same remark from a Kalshi spokesperson.

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said in a statement that "Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents," CoinDesk reported. He added that federal commodities rules were not designed to provide those safeguards.

What comes next

Maryland had agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi while the appeal was pending, InGame reported, and the state may now go to state court to seek a ban on the contracts. Kalshi could ask the full Fourth Circuit to rehear the case or take it to the Supreme Court, according to InGame, which also reported that New Jersey asked the Supreme Court in September to review the Third Circuit's ruling and that Kalshi's response there is due December 7.

The ruling also lands as the CFTC presses exchanges to offer contracts in every state. CoinDesk noted that the agency's 30-day deadline for its push to end state-by-state geofencing is close, which could leave exchanges choosing between court orders and their federal regulator. On November 17, senators pressed the two CFTC nominees on the state fight, the same day CNBC reported that Kalshi had halted its Trump mention contracts after the agency stayed their certification.

What it could mean for prediction market users

In our assessment, the ruling matters less for its vote than for its reasoning. With no shared rationale in the majority, the Fourth Circuit adds a result for the states without settling whether sports contracts are swaps, so the question the circuits disagree on remains open. For Maryland users, access to Kalshi's sports contracts now depends on what the state does next in court and on whether Kalshi seeks further review. Dates to watch are December 7 in the New Jersey petition and the end of the CFTC's 30-day window.

Sources

This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.

Trading Metrics · Trading journal and performance analytics platform

Trading Metrics (tradingmetrics.com) is a trading journal and performance analytics platform with the same owner as this publication. Articles under this byline are researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked against their sources in a separate fact-check and editorial review, and published only after the owner has approved them.