Judge acquits Peraire-Bueno brothers in $25 million Ethereum MEV case a year after jury deadlock
Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that prosecutors never proved a material misrepresentation, a required element of wire fraud, and entered acquittals on all three counts without a retrial.

Contents
A federal judge in Manhattan on Monday, November 16, 2026, acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud, wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy in the $25 million Ethereum MEV case. US District Judge Jessica Clarke granted the brothers' motion for a judgment of acquittal, ruling that the government "failed to prove that the Peraire-Buenos made any material misrepresentations," according to her 46-page opinion and order. She directed the clerk to close the case.
The acquittal came from the judge, not from a jury, and there was no second trial. The brothers' first trial, which ran nearly four weeks, ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after jurors deliberated for three days without reaching a unanimous verdict, the opinion says. The ruling decides the motion the brothers made during that trial and renewed after the mistrial.
What prosecutors alleged
Prosecutors charged the brothers in May 2024. According to the opinion, they said the pair carried out a scheme known as "Omakase" in April 2023 that took about $25 million in 12 seconds from three traders who ran automated "sandwich" trading bots. MEV stands for maximal extractable value, the profit available from how transactions are ordered in a block.
The court described the scheme in these terms: the brothers sent "lure transactions" built to attract the bots, used a flaw in MEV-Boost relay software, a system built by Flashbots, to see the bots' pending trades, and then proposed a block that swapped the lure transactions for their own trades, so the bots lost the tokens they had sold. Their validator was penalized ("slashed") 1 ETH for proposing two blocks for one slot. Flashbots changed the relay code within 24 hours, and one wallet holding $3 million of the proceeds was frozen, the opinion says.
The final indictment carried four counts. The court dismissed a fourth charge, conspiracy to receive stolen property, before trial after the government said it would not proceed on it. The three counts that went to the jury are the ones on which Clarke entered acquittals.
Why the judge ruled for the brothers
Wire fraud requires a false or fraudulent representation, and Clarke found none in the evidence. She rejected each of the government's theories:
- The lure transactions made no promise about where they would land on the blockchain, and they were not canceled: they were published in a block about a minute later.
- The spoofing comparison failed because the trades "were not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct," unlike the regulated markets in earlier spoofing cases.
- The validator's signature on a block it knew would fail was not false; it was a commitment to propose that block or be slashed, and the validator was slashed.
- The "honest validator" theory, that the brothers broke MEV-Boost's specifications, could not by itself make the conduct fraud.
Clarke wrote that the government cannot substitute the scheme as a whole, or evidence that the brothers hid their identities afterward, for a specific misrepresentation. Because the money laundering count depended on wire fraud proceeds, it fell with the fraud counts. The opinion cites United States v. Eisenberg, a 2025 decision in the same court that acquitted Avraham Eisenberg of wire fraud over more than $100 million he borrowed and withdrew from the Mango Markets platform, because the government had not proved a false statement.
"This case is not about whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct 'was improper, objectionable, or even despicable,'" Clarke wrote, quoting an earlier Second Circuit ruling.
What both sides said
Lawyers for the brothers had no immediate comment, and a spokesperson for the US Attorney's office that brought the case declined to comment, Reuters reported. At a hearing in March, Assistant US Attorney Danielle Kudla argued that the bait transactions and the invalid signature were deceptions, while Patrick Looby, a lawyer for James Peraire-Bueno, compared the case with the Eisenberg acquittal, DL News reported. Prosecutors wanted a retrial at the time, according to the same report, and had appealed the Eisenberg acquittal. After the mistrial, a lawyer for Anton Peraire-Bueno, Daniel Marx, said the brothers "should be celebrated, not vilified," Bloomberg reported.
Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of the crypto policy group Coin Center, which filed a friend-of-the-court brief against the "honest validator" theory, called the ruling "excellent news" on X at 20:20 UTC on Monday. He wrote that the government's theory would have let it impose "its own code of conduct on Ethereum validators."
The Justice Department has used wire fraud charges in other crypto trading cases. In September it charged two former Robinhood engineers with commodities fraud and wire fraud over alleged trading ahead of listing announcements, The Block has reported. On the same Monday, the Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank's case for a Federal Reserve master account.
What it could mean for traders
In our assessment, the ruling matters because it tests whether exploiting how a blockchain's software works, without a false statement to anyone, can be prosecuted as wire fraud. Two judges in the Southern District of New York have now answered no on the evidence before them, in Eisenberg and in this case, and both opinions point to the absence of exchange rules or terms of use that would make a trade an implied promise. The opinion is a trial court ruling, not an appeals decision, and Clarke said she was not deciding whether the conduct broke other laws that were not charged.
Sources
- US District Court for the Southern District of New York — United States v. Peraire-Bueno, No. 24-CR-293 (JGLC), Opinion and Order (ECF No. 294) (November 16, 2026)
- Peter Van Valkenburgh (Coin Center) on X — Post on the Peraire-Bueno acquittal (November 16, 2026)
- Reuters (via The Jerusalem Post) — US judge clears MIT-educated brothers of $25 million cryptocurrency heist charges (November 17, 2026)
- The Block — Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted of wire fraud in $25 million Ethereum MEV case (November 16, 2026)
- DL News — Court dispatch: MEV bros point to Eisenberg acquittal in high-stakes hearing (March 13, 2026)
- Bloomberg (via Insurance Journal) — Mistrial declared in case of MIT brothers accused of $25 million crypto theft (November 10, 2025)
This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.
This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.