Regulation

Why a judge cleared the Peraire-Bueno brothers: Ethereum has 'no terms of use,' and code specs are not rules

Judge Jessica Clarke's 46-page opinion found no rule on Ethereum or MEV-Boost that could turn a trade or a validator signature into a promise, and said the prosecution raised serious due process concerns.

Contents
  1. Why "no terms of use" mattered
  2. Incentives instead of rules
  3. "Honest" as a term of art
  4. Shifting theories and a due process warning
  5. What prosecutors and the defense said
  6. What it could mean for on-chain traders

When US District Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, November 16, 2026, in the $25 million Ethereum MEV case, the deciding question was not whether their trades were fair. It was whether anything on Ethereum could have made those trades a promise. Her 46-page opinion and order answers no, and much of its reasoning turns on how the network is built. Ethereum, she wrote, is "a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," a line CoinDesk highlighted in its report on the ruling at 05:30 UTC on Wednesday, November 18.

Why "no terms of use" mattered

Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation. Prosecutors argued that the brothers' "lure" transactions, sent to attract automated sandwich-trading bots, implicitly promised to execute as part of a bundle. Clarke's opinion says an implied promise of that kind needs something to give a trade its meaning, such as an exchange rule against deceptive orders. That is how earlier spoofing convictions worked. It is also what was missing in United States v. Eisenberg, the 2025 Mango Markets case in which the same court acquitted on a wire fraud charge; there, the opinion notes, no terms of service or other rules prohibited the conduct.

The government said the rules existed within MEV-Boost, the block-building software from Flashbots that most Ethereum users employed, according to the opinion. Clarke disagreed. MEV-Boost "lacked terms of use or any independent mechanism to enforce behavior," she wrote, and the documents prosecutors pointed to were "simply the MEV-Boost computer code's specifications," not rules governing user conduct. A footnote adds that MEV-Boost's GitHub page refers to a code of conduct, but that document was never introduced at trial.

She also found no evidence that any such rules bound the brothers. According to the opinion, the government's lead witness testified that they were not running MEV-Boost when they carried out the scheme, and their validator used the Ultrasound relay, not one run by Flashbots. No one from Ultrasound testified. A validator that registers with a relay agrees to no terms of use and commits to nothing in the future, the opinion says, citing trial testimony.

Incentives instead of rules

The opinion repeatedly returns to the idea that Ethereum is designed to work without trust. Citing the government's own witnesses, Clarke wrote that the network "relies primarily on economic incentives to influence validator behavior and lacks rules by design." Under the protocol, a validator may order transactions in a block however it chooses, and users expect validators to act in their own rational self-interest, "whatever that is."

That framing decided the signature theory. Prosecutors said that when the brothers' validator signed a block header with two fields set to zero, it falsely promised to publish a valid block. Clarke found the signature was an accurate commitment either to propose that block or to be penalized, and the validator was penalized. She added that the network's consensus nodes build in the assumption that validators may propose invalid blocks "out of strategy or incompetence."

The signature also failed on materiality. The Ultrasound relay did not check those fields before releasing the block's contents, so the false data "had no impact on the behavior of its recipient," she wrote. CoinDesk's report summarized the same point: the relay never checked the signature data.

"Honest" as a term of art

Prosecutors had argued that the brothers posed as an "honest MEV-Boost validator." The opinion treats "honest" as a technical label rather than a moral one, quoting trial testimony that "honesty is a term of art" on Ethereum and that an honest validator is one that signs only one block. A validator that signs two blocks, Clarke wrote, merely agrees to be slashed.

She added that the system's own designers expect users to capture value wherever they can, a principle that Flashbots' Bert Miller, the government's lead witness, and other technology designers call being "MEV aware." Proposer-builder separation, the split between those who build and those who propose blocks that MEV-Boost relies on, had not been adopted into Ethereum's protocol as of the trial, the opinion notes. Frustrating the spirit of MEV-Boost's design, Clarke wrote, citing a 2022 Second Circuit ruling on Libor submissions, is not by itself fraud.

Shifting theories and a due process warning

The opinion is critical of how the government framed its case. A footnote describes the court's repeated attempts, from the motion-to-dismiss stage onward, to pin down which misrepresentations prosecutors were relying on. At one point the government listed seven, and its theories shifted again in its later briefing and at oral argument, the footnote says. Clarke called one list a "laundry list" that boiled down to three features of the scheme.

She also rejected the argument that the scheme as a whole could stand in for a specific false statement. The government cannot avoid that element "by gesturing generally at a scheme," she wrote, and evidence that the brothers hid their plans goes to intent, a separate element. In another footnote she declined to rule on whether the indictment violated the brothers' due process rights, but wrote that the prosecution "raises serious due process concerns."

What prosecutors and the defense said

A spokesperson for US Attorney James McDonald, whose office brought the case, declined to comment, and lawyers for the brothers had no immediate comment, Reuters reported. CoinDesk's report carried no statement from either side, and neither report mentions an appeal; we could not check the court docket directly. The Justice Department has continued to bring wire fraud charges in crypto trading cases: in September it charged two former Robinhood engineers with commodities fraud and wire fraud over alleged trading ahead of listing announcements, The Block has reported.

What it could mean for on-chain traders

In our assessment, the opinion's most consequential reasoning is that, on Ethereum, a trade or a signature means only what the protocol and its software say it means, unless some binding rule adds more. That differs from regulated exchanges, where rulebooks give an order an implied meaning. The ruling does not bless the conduct: Clarke said she was not deciding whether it was right or moral, or whether it broke laws that were not charged. It is a trial court ruling that binds no other court.

Sources

This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.

Trading Metrics · Trading journal and performance analytics platform

Trading Metrics (tradingmetrics.com) is a trading journal and performance analytics platform with the same owner as this publication. Articles under this byline are researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked against their sources in a separate fact-check and editorial review, and published only after the owner has approved them.