Regulation

SEC proposes taking direct control of the Consolidated Audit Trail and paying for it from its budget

The proposal would scrap Rule 613 and the exchange-run plan behind the market surveillance database, keep largely the same reporting duties for brokers and exchanges, and fund the system through congressional appropriations.

Contents
  1. What the CAT is
  2. What the proposal would change
  3. Why the SEC wants control
  4. Who pays
  5. Vote and comment period
  6. What it could mean for brokers and traders

The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on Friday, November 20, 2026, proposed to take direct control of the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT), the database regulators use to follow orders in US stocks and listed options across exchanges and brokers. The agency would replace the exchange-run plan that owns the system today with its own reporting rule and pay its costs from the budget Congress gives it.

What the CAT is

The SEC adopted Rule 613 in 2012. It required the national securities exchanges and national securities associations, the self-regulatory organizations (SROs), to jointly build and run a market-wide audit trail through a national market system plan, according to the SEC's fact sheet. The commission approved that plan, the CAT NMS Plan, in 2016.

The system is meant to give the SEC and the SROs a linked record of "the full lifecycle of all orders" in listed stocks and options and in over-the-counter equities, the fact sheet says. The proposing release describes its uses as market surveillance, investigations, examinations, and market reconstructions. Today the CAT is owned by the SROs through CAT LLC and operated by FINRA CAT, a subsidiary of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).

What the proposal would change

The SEC says the proposal is about who runs and pays for the CAT, not about what it collects. Under the plan:

  • Rule 613 would be rescinded. The SEC expects the SROs to then ask it to rescind the CAT NMS Plan and their related compliance rules.
  • A new Rule 17a-26 would take its place. It would require SROs and broker-dealers to record and report to the SEC or its designee substantially the same data as today, including exemptive relief already granted, without otherwise changing those duties in substance, the fact sheet says.
  • Some details would change. Certain clock synchronization requirements that now apply only to broker-dealers would extend to the SROs. A written error-correction policies requirement, reviewed at least once a year, would replace the current compliance thresholds. Records would have to be kept for at least three years.
  • The existing system would be taken over, not rebuilt. The SEC expects to arrange the sale and transfer of CAT assets, sign a contract with a designee to run the system, and set up new advisory committees or working groups. Building a new audit trail would be "costly, time-consuming, and inefficient," the release says.

On customer data, the release says the CAT no longer collects customer and account-level information after amendments the SEC approved. Firms would still report transformed identifiers that let regulators link a customer's orders without storing Social Security numbers. The SEC says it is not proposing to collect any new personally identifiable information. It also declined a commenter's suggestion to restore some of the information that was removed.

Why the SEC wants control

The SEC says the CAT's decentralized governance "has presented certain challenges" in running the system. In his statement, Chairman Paul Atkins said CAT operating costs "ballooned to nearly $250 million a year" and that its data collection "created unnecessary risks to investors' privacy." Atkins said that since he ordered a review of the CAT after taking office, exemptive relief and plan amendments have cut its annual operating costs by more than $100 million. The SEC's press release describes the same savings as a cut in projected annual operating costs.

Commissioner Mark Uyeda wrote in his statement that annual operating costs were estimated at about $55 million when the plan was approved in 2016 and that the projected budget approached $250 million by 2024. He said the SEC itself expanded the CAT's scope and is among its main users but has not paid for it. "The Commission should be responsible for the costs of operating the regulatory infrastructure that it requires and relies upon," he wrote.

The SEC says comments on its April 2026 concept release showed support from investors and market participants for the agency taking more control over the CAT's management and funding. CAT LLC said in its comment that it would "not oppose exploring the potential transition" if structured under appropriate conditions, and it listed issues such as asset transfers, contracts, and pending claims that would need to be resolved first, the release says.

Who pays

The CAT is now funded by the SROs and broker-dealers under a 2026 funding model, with fees split evenly among the SROs, executing brokers for buyers, and executing brokers for sellers, the release says. That model bars billing broker-dealers for CAT fees after March 31, 2028.

Under the proposal, the SEC would use appropriated funds for its own costs of using, operating, and maintaining the CAT. Those appropriations are offset by Section 31 fees collected from exchanges and FINRA, which in practice pass them to their members. The securities industry group SIFMA, quoted in the release, said in its comment that the industry "would still ultimately pay" for the CAT through Section 31, but that putting the cost in the SEC's budget would better align incentives to control it. SROs would still pay for their own access to and use of the data, the SEC says, and the release does not rule out access or usage fees, which SRO commenters opposed.

The SEC's economic analysis bases its cost estimate on the current CAT budget, since it does not expect operating costs to change significantly under the new structure. Separately, the SEC said that on the same day it granted exemptive relief letting the SROs recover certain historical development and implementation costs from broker-dealers.

Vote and comment period

The SEC currently has two commissioners, Atkins and Uyeda, according to its list of commissioners. Uyeda said he was "pleased to support the proposal." The documents do not give a vote count. President Donald Trump nominated two more commissioners on November 12, and the nominees appeared at their confirmation hearing on November 19.

Comments are due 60 days after publication in the Federal Register under file number S7-2026-40. The release had not yet been published there when we checked on November 21.

What it could mean for brokers and traders

In our assessment, the proposal as written would change little in broker-dealers' day-to-day reporting, since the SEC says the data and formats would stay largely the same. The bigger shift is who decides what the CAT costs and who signs off on that spending. Moving the bill into the SEC's budget puts CAT spending under the congressional appropriations process, but the cost still reaches the industry through Section 31 fees. Open points to watch are the terms of any sale of CAT assets, whether SROs end up paying access fees, and how the comment period treats the funding questions the SROs have raised.

Sources

This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.

Trading Metrics · Trading journal and performance analytics platform

Trading Metrics (tradingmetrics.com) is a trading journal and performance analytics platform with the same owner as this publication. Articles under this byline are researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked against their sources in a separate fact-check and editorial review, and published only after the owner has approved them.