Regulation

Kalshi fights New York's restraining order bid after a federal judge sends the state's case back to state court

A Manhattan state judge has set a hearing for Monday, November 23, on the attorney general's request, ABC News reported. Kalshi and the CFTC say the order could halt the New York-based exchange entirely; the state says no irreparable harm has been shown.

Contents
  1. Why the case is back in state court
  2. What Kalshi asked the state judge
  3. The state's renewed request and the federal effort to stop it
  4. Kalshi's other court fights
  5. What it could mean for Kalshi users

Kalshi is trying to stop New York from getting a court order that the prediction market says could halt its business. On Thursday, November 19, 2026, US District Judge Vernon S. Broderick of the Southern District of New York sent the New York attorney general's lawsuit against Kalshi back to state court. The same night, Kalshi asked the state judge not to grant any restraining order before hearing from the company.

Why the case is back in state court

New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Kalshi on July 31, 2026, alleging that it runs an unlicensed gambling business. The state is seeking an order to stop that business, forfeiture of the gains, restitution and fines of three times the gains, according to the attorney general's office. "No matter what they call themselves, prediction markets like Kalshi are gambling platforms, plain and simple," James said at the time.

Kalshi moved the case to federal court the same day. In his 19-page opinion, Broderick rejected both of the company's grounds for federal jurisdiction: the federal officer removal statute, which Kalshi tied to its Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) license, and the argument that the claims turn on federal law. Gambling regulation is "clearly a matter of predominantly state concern," he wrote, quoting an earlier ruling. He denied New York's request for legal fees, finding that Kalshi had an "objectively reasonable basis" for removal, and said he could not decide Kalshi's motion for a protective order because his court lacked jurisdiction.

The ruling decides only which court hears the case. It leaves open whether Kalshi's event contracts break New York law.

What Kalshi asked the state judge

Kalshi's lawyers at Milbank filed a letter to Justice Crane in the state case, People ex rel. James v. KalshiEX LLC (index number 453272/2026), late on November 19. The first page of the letter was posted on X by gaming lawyer Daniel Wallach; Trading Notified read that page but not the rest of the four-page filing.

The letter says the state had applied for an ex parte TRO, meaning one issued without hearing from Kalshi, when it filed the suit. That application was denied as moot after the removal, "without prejudice to a new motion should the federal court remand," according to the letter. Kalshi argued that any renewed request should be briefed by both sides, and that the earlier proposed order had "extraterritorial effects that extend well beyond this Court's jurisdiction." It also said the order would put it at risk of violating a CFTC directive, leaving it "in an impossible position at the center of an irreconcilable federal/state conflict." Kalshi also asked for a prompt status conference, Wallach wrote.

The state's renewed request and the federal effort to stop it

An assistant attorney general filed a proposed motion for a TRO on Friday, CoinDesk reported. The request would stop Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission, and Crane set a hearing for Monday, ABC News reported. According to the New York Post, Kalshi's lawyers said the state's proposed order covered contracts offered "within or from New York."

The CFTC tried to block it. In a filing in federal court on Friday, the agency argued that a New York halt would force Kalshi to "cease all operations" because the company is based in New York, CoinDesk reported. CFTC lawyer Andrew Weisberg said the state's order "would completely shut down Kalshi's operations nationwide," according to ABC News, which reported on an emergency telephone hearing before Judge Schofield. Kate Rhodes Janofsky of the attorney general's office said federal intervention had no basis while a state hearing was scheduled. "They have to put in evidence of irreparable harm. They have not done so," she said. Schofield ruled: "The requested application is denied," ABC News reported.

The two sides disagree on the order's reach. ABC News reported that the lawsuit does not seek to shut Kalshi down but could force changes to how it operates. Kalshi lawyer Sean Murphy told Crane that a TRO "would likely force the liquidation of all open positions," according to ABC News. In August, the CFTC said the state's requested order would bar Kalshi from offering all event contracts nationwide, and it used its emergency authority to direct Kalshi to keep operating. Broderick noted in a footnote that Kalshi's own briefing said the suit seeks to "shut down Kalshi's exchange altogether, including in states other than New York."

Kalshi spokeswoman Elisabeth Diana said the company "has been compliant with the law since day one," CoinDesk and the New York Post reported. She said Kalshi wants to work with the governor and the attorney general on a resolution that "protects the interests of the 1.2 million New Yorkers who use Kalshi," CoinDesk reported.

Kalshi's other court fights

New York has pressed Kalshi on more than one front. The state Gaming Commission sent the company a cease-and-desist letter on October 24, 2025, and Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi's request for a preliminary injunction against the commission on July 7, 2026, according to Broderick's opinion. Kalshi's appeal of that ruling is pending at the Second Circuit. On November 10, another judge in the same court denied Novig's bid to block New York's gambling law.

Elsewhere, the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 against Kalshi in its Maryland case on November 18, and the CFTC has sued Louisiana over a state restraining order against prediction markets.

What it could mean for Kalshi users

In our assessment, the New York case differs from Kalshi's other state fights because the company is based in the state, which is why Kalshi and the CFTC describe the possible effect as nationwide while the state frames its request around unlicensed sports contracts. Neither side's description has been tested by the state court yet. The points to watch are the hearing before Justice Crane that ABC News reported for Monday, November 23, the exact scope of any order she issues, how Kalshi reconciles it with the CFTC's directive, and the Second Circuit appeal in the Gaming Commission case.

Sources

This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.

Trading Metrics · Trading journal and performance analytics platform

Trading Metrics (tradingmetrics.com) is a trading journal and performance analytics platform with the same owner as this publication. Articles under this byline are researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked against their sources in a separate fact-check and editorial review, and published only after the owner has approved them.