Coinbase backs CFTC rules that define event contracts as swaps and keep casino gambling out
In two letters dated November 18, the comment deadline, Coinbase urged the CFTC to finalize its event contract proposal with an open-ended list of examples and endorsed the interim rule excluding sportsbooks and casino games.

Contents
Coinbase has told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that it supports two agency actions that would draw a line between prediction markets and gambling: a proposal to define event contracts, including those on sports, politics, culture and weather, as swaps, and an interim rule that keeps casino games and sportsbook wagers out of that definition. The exchange's two comment letters are dated Wednesday, November 18, 2026, the last day for public comments on both, and were reported by The Block.
What the CFTC proposed
Both actions were published in the Federal Register on October 19, 2026. The proposed rule would add one line to the definition of "swap" in the CFTC's rules, covering "Event contracts, including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural, and weather-related events." The agency describes that list as non-exhaustive. A swap is the broad category of derivatives that Congress placed under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction in the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act, and an event contract pays out depending on whether a specified event happens.
The interim final rule took effect on publication and asked for comments afterward. It excludes a product from the swap definition only if two conditions are met. The provider must be licensed or authorized under state or tribal law to offer gambling and be acting within that license, with the product regulated as gambling. The product must also not be traded on an exchange, a swap execution facility or any other multilateral market. Sports wagers, casino table games and slot machines, and games of chance such as bingo, lotteries and raffles are named as examples.
Comments on both were due by November 18. Chairman Michael Selig voted for both documents and no commissioner voted against, according to their voting summaries.
What Coinbase asks for
In its letter on the proposal, signed by Julia Hueckel, director of regulatory policy, and David Shafer, director and associate general counsel, Coinbase argues that event contracts already meet the statutory definition of a swap and that the rule would only make this explicit. It asks the CFTC to:
- keep the "including" wording and say in the final release that the four examples are not a closed set; "A closed list would provide less certainty," the letter says
- state that the rule confirms existing law, rather than suggesting the listed contracts become swaps only when the rule takes effect
- say it is both adopting the best reading of the statute and using its delegated authority to further define "swap"
- explain that the benefits would outweigh the costs even if a court treated state regulation of sports and other event contracts as the starting point
The letter names digital-asset and blockchain events, technology and scientific milestones, and economic developments as subjects that an open list should leave room for. It says conflicting court rulings create uncertainty that fractures market depth and liquidity.
Why Coinbase says prediction markets are not sportsbooks
In its letter on the interim rule, Coinbase writes: "Casino games and sportsbook wagers are not derivatives, and they have long been regulated by the States and tribes." It argues that the rule correctly turns on market structure rather than subject matter. An event contract exchange, the letter says, acts as a "neutral market operator" that does not set prices or trade against its members and is indifferent to whether any customer wins or loses. A sportsbook, by contrast, sets the odds and takes the other side of each bet, according to the letter.
On that reading, a football wager at a licensed sportsbook falls outside federal jurisdiction, while an event contract on the same game listed on a CFTC-registered exchange remains a swap. "There is no sports exception to the CEA," the letter says, referring to the Commodity Exchange Act.
Coinbase discloses its own stake in both letters. It owns Coinbase Derivatives, a CFTC-registered exchange, and Coinbase Financial Markets, a registered futures commission merchant through which it offers event contracts to customers nationwide, and it says it recently registered Coinbase Clearing as a clearinghouse.
Courts and states disagree
The CFTC's position is contested. Several states argue that some event contracts violate their gambling laws, The Block reported. The CFTC and the Justice Department have sued states including Arkansas and Louisiana to defend the agency's jurisdiction; on November 13, the CFTC said Louisiana was the 12th state it had sued.
On November 10, a federal judge in New York denied Novig's request for a preliminary injunction against New York's gambling laws. According to Coinbase's letter, which quotes the ruling, the court declined to adopt the interim rule's distinction between sportsbook bets and sports event contracts and said it need not defer to the agency's view. Coinbase says the district court erred and urges the CFTC to keep stressing that it is using authority Congress expressly delegated to it. Federal appeals courts have also split on whether sports event contracts are swaps, the letter says.
Prediction markets also came up at the Senate hearing for President Trump's CFTC nominees on November 17.
We read the signed letters as PDF files linked by The Block; we could not confirm whether they have been posted to the CFTC's public comment record.
What it could mean for prediction market users
In our assessment, the two rules would not by themselves settle where users in each state can trade. The interim rule is already in force but has been rejected by one federal court, and the inclusion rule is still a proposal; the CFTC must review the comments before it can adopt a final version. The next markers are whether and when the agency finalizes the proposal, and how appeals courts and the pending state cases treat the two rules.
Sources
- Coinbase — Comment letter on Further Definition of Swap: Inclusions (RIN 3038-AF82) (November 18, 2026)
- Coinbase — Comment letter on the interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling (RIN 3038-AF81) (November 18, 2026)
- Federal Register (Commodity Futures Trading Commission) — Further Definition of Swap: Inclusions (proposed rule, 91 FR 66022) (October 19, 2026)
- Federal Register (Commodity Futures Trading Commission) — Further Definition of Swap To Exclude Casino-Style Gambling Products (interim final rule, 91 FR 65969) (October 19, 2026)
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission — CFTC Sues Louisiana After State Court Blocks CFTC-Regulated Exchanges (November 13, 2026)
- The Block — Coinbase backs CFTC proposal to distinguish prediction market contracts from gambling (November 20, 2026)
This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.
This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.