CryptoUK asks the FCA to say that building or governing DeFi is not by itself a regulated activity
The trade group broadly backs the regulator's draft perimeter guidance, but says parts of it could catch open-source developers and governance token holders and go further than the law.

Contents
CryptoUK, a UK crypto trade association that says it has more than 150 member companies, has asked the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to state plainly that writing, maintaining or securing decentralized finance (DeFi) software, or taking part in its governance, does not on its own mean a person is carrying on a regulated activity. The request is in the group's response to consultation paper CP26/36, dated November 18, 2026, the day the consultation closed.
What the FCA proposed
The FCA opened CP26/36 on October 21, 2026, and took responses until November 18. It proposes changes to the Perimeter Guidance Manual (PERG), the part of the FCA Handbook that explains when a firm needs authorization. The changes reflect a second statutory instrument, the Cryptoassets (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2026, which added exclusions from the new regime.
Those exclusions cover, among other things, temporary settlement arrangements, backing assets for UK qualifying stablecoins (stablecoins issued under UK permission), proprietary trading and market making, and technical services that only give access to a third party's service or to a decentralized protocol, according to the regulator.
The paper also adds new guidance on decentralization. In the consultation paper, the FCA says the perimeter is technology neutral and that calling an arrangement decentralized, or DeFi, "does not, on its own, mean that there is no relevant person." Depending on the facts, it says, a relevant person may include someone who "determines or materially influences" the design or parameters of an automated arrangement.
The draft also accepts that some arrangements described as DeFi "may involve no person carrying on a regulated activity," because software and smart contracts are not persons that can be authorized. The FCA says each case turns on its facts and that decentralization "operates on a spectrum."
What CryptoUK asks for
In the cover letter, signed by policy director Nick Brooks, CryptoUK says it broadly supports the proposed guidance. On DeFi, it points to what it calls the FCA's "clear controlling person" approach and says the guidance should separate effective control of a regulated financial service from "historic, collective or purely technical involvement in a protocol."
The group says the "materially influences" wording, read alone, could catch open-source developers, upgrade contributors or governance token holders. It asks the FCA to require "a current, material connection" between a person's role and the regulated activity. Publishing code, fixing vulnerabilities, being paid for development or security work, and voting in decentralized governance should not by themselves be enough, it says.
CryptoUK also asks the FCA to confirm that holding or voting governance tokens, receiving grants or bounties for code or audits, and running a node or validator are unlikely, on their own, to amount to running a regulated crypto business. It adds that giving up all upgrade or administrative powers for good should not be a condition for developers to be protected.
The UK territorial link
A second objection concerns where an activity takes place. The draft says that UK-based people involved in the governance, operation, maintenance or development of decentralized arrangements "may be sufficient to establish a territorial link with the UK."
CryptoUK says this "goes beyond the legislation." In its view, the test is whether the regulated activity itself is carried on in the UK, and a UK-based developer does not by itself make that so. It warns that a broad reading could deter UK developers from open-source projects "without any consumer protection benefit," and suggests saying that development or maintenance alone is unlikely to be enough.
Other requests
The response, prepared with law firm CMS, also asks for a public, machine-readable record of UK qualifying stablecoins that firms can rely on, clearer lines between stablecoins and electronic money, and more examples of activity that usually falls outside the perimeter. It asks the FCA to raise with HM Treasury cases where UK firms are at a disadvantage, such as UK providers giving access to overseas regulated venues, and to align with the EU's Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) rules "where appropriate."
CryptoUK published the response on its website and summarized its main asks on X on November 19. Decrypt reported it on November 20. The FCA has not yet published its feedback on the consultation; it says it will take the feedback it receives into account in its final guidance.
What comes next
The FCA's consultation web page says it aims to publish final perimeter guidance in January 2027, while the consultation paper itself says spring 2027. A separate FCA consultation, GC26/7, covers operational resilience and financial crime guidance for regulated firms that use DeFi; it closed on the same day, and final guidance is also planned for January 2027.
The FCA also said it would give some firms extra time to complete the arranging permission part of their applications if they can show that uncertainty over the technical services exclusion materially affected their ability to apply. The application window for firms with existing UK crypto business closes on February 28, 2027. Separately, the FCA, the Bank of England and the Prudential Regulation Authority opened a consultation on November 19 on draft cyber resilience guidance for financial firms.
What it could mean for DeFi developers and UK users
In our assessment, the outcome turns on wording. If the final guidance keeps the "materially influences" test and the UK territorial link as drafted, more people working on protocols from the UK may have to consider whether they need authorization. If the FCA adopts CryptoUK's narrower reading, the focus stays on whoever actually controls a service. The UK's approach can be compared with the US, where CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, in an interview reported by The Block, said onchain venues can enter the US by registering or partnering with an exchange. Points to watch are the FCA's feedback statement, any change to the draft PERG 18.1.17 and 18.3.1A text, and how many firms ask for the extra application time.
Sources
- CryptoUK — Response to CP26/36: Cryptoasset Perimeter Guidance (letter to the FCA, PDF) (November 18, 2026)
- CryptoUK — CryptoUK's response to FCA CP26/36: Cryptoasset Perimeter Guidance (November 19, 2026)
- Financial Conduct Authority — CP26/36: Cryptoasset perimeter guidance (October 21, 2026)
- Financial Conduct Authority — Consultation Paper CP26/36: Cryptoasset Perimeter Guidance (PDF) (October 21, 2026)
- Financial Conduct Authority — GC26/7: Decentralised finance guidance (DeFi) (October 21, 2026)
- CryptoUK on X — CryptoUK post on its CP26/36 response (November 19, 2026)
- Decrypt — CryptoUK Urges FCA Not to Treat DeFi Devs as Regulated by Default (November 20, 2026)
This article was researched and drafted with the help of AI tools, checked against its sources in a separate AI fact-check and edit, and approved for publication by Trading Metrics. Read our AI use policy.
This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto assets and leveraged products are volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and consider your circumstances before trading.